What those little cauldrons mean
Or "Ceri's Book Review Scale"
Scales generally frustrate me because I don't know what they really mean, and because people sometimes hesitate to give low ratings out of a sense of guilt. My intent with this scale is to be absolutely frank and for the scale ratings to be clearly given. With that in mind, here is a list of how I'm grading. I'm not the type to give something 3 cauldrons if it's really bad. The books that get 5 cauldrons will be rare. Hopefully, the books with 0 or 1 cauldrons will be rare too, but it's not a rating I will hesitate to give.
No Cauldrons: This book is not worth reading. Don't waste your money, your time, or your valuable shelf space. Unless, of course, you like keeping books you can burn for heat in particularly cold winters.
One Cauldron: If someone gives you this book, don't throw it out, but you're better off skimming it at your local bookstore for the two or three interesting tidbits it contains. It also likely contains a lot of misinformation, so check any fact that sounds wrong.
Two Cauldrons: Some worthwhile information here, but the book's flaws outweigh its merits. Pick it up used for cheap, or borrow it from a friend.
Three Cauldrons: I have a few sizeable complaints, but overall this book has some good information and is worth picking up used.
Four Cauldrons: My complaints are few and nitpicky. It's a great read, great information, and highly recommended.
Five Cauldrons: No complaints, and one I would recommend for any collection of Pagan/Wiccan books. It's a must-have, worth paying the exorbitant cover price for.
***
Return to the Spirituality Page